Skip to content
← All insights

Article·Marketing Leadership

CMOs don't want more vendors, they want one partner who gets it right

The agency model built on scale and headcount is giving way to smaller, AI-first teams. Why PR and marketing rarely need two separate invoices any more.

By Jennifer Compton, CEO & Founder·

Most CMOs don’t want another AI platform pitch. They want a person or a small team that can be their strategic, smart and honest partner. Someone who helps them make the right call, brings good ideas, and doesn’t just push tools or campaigns that won’t deliver. The old agency model, built on scale and headcount, is being replaced by smaller, agile, AI-first teams who can actually help CMOs put AI to work instead of just selling it to them.

Not only am I hearing this from clients but it was also my takeaway from a session, “what’s next for full-service agencies,” at Cannes hosted by accountancy and tax advisory firm HaysMac, with panelists Tony Walford and Luke Clark among others. They work a lot with entrepreneurs through different growth stages of their business and the discussion centered around specialist vs. full-service agencies, and what buyers, brands, and talent increasingly value in today’s market, and it’s a partner who can gut check a decision and help CMOs get a project across the finish line.

But it is not just about AI. It is also about consolidation. CMOs are tired of buying more tools, more vendors, and briefing more people. Especially with AI. They want simplification. Fewer relationships that actually do more for them.

That logic also applies to how agencies have been split. Especially PR and marketing. Most of my connections here know I am a PR person. That is what I like doing. I started J&L Communications as a PR business. But ten years ago, PR was a tough sell. Clients wanted immediate results in top tier publications only and didn’t understand the slow burn that is PR success. So, we found ourselves moving more into marketing and communications as a way to bridge the gap. It is a close cousin, and you use a lot of the same skills and the payout tends to be quicker.

Fast forward ten years and GEO and AEO are changing how brands get found. Credibility is the new currency. Nothing signals credibility like a third-party story in a trade publication written by an industry expert. AI engines are starting to weight that pedigree the same way readers always have. PR is having a moment because of it.

Typically, CMOs still run two separate retainers. One for PR and one for marketing. But why when the work overlaps so much? In our experience roughly half the budget goes to each and some of that spend gets wasted. Marketing and comms teams are usually the ones who can develop a sharp point of view or strong commentary and creative that can live across all channels. PR teams are the ones who know how to pitch it to the earned ones. But you need senior PR folks who know the client’s business looking at the pitches. You need both skill sets. You rarely need two separate invoices.

Paid builds reach, earned builds trust, owned builds consistency, and together they give AI engines the redundancy they need to confidently cite a brand.

Paid, earned and owned work best as one system. Split that across multiple agencies and that consistency is the first thing to break down.

We’ve played well in the sandbox with PR agencies. We wrote the content, they pitched it, and the results were strong. That’s one model. But lately, as clients push for more GEO and a simpler overall process, we’ve started doing both PR and marketing again ourselves. Running focused PR sprints where a senior strategist handles both the content and the pitching, with clear deliverables, agreed target publications, and a sharp point of view from the subject matter expert. One person or a small team making both calls.

With AI adding so many new decisions and teams still catching up, CMOs are rejecting more complexity. Fewer relationships that do more. That’s the model we built J&L around, and it’s exactly what CMOs are asking for right now.