Article·Marketing Leadership
The Rise of the Consulting Agency
Stop selling services and sell client outcomes. Why AI collapsing production time breaks the hours model, and what an agency should be measured on instead.
By Jennifer Compton, CEO & Founder·
As the founder of a small independent agency, this is how I’m thinking about the future of our business: stop selling services and sell client outcomes.
The traditional agency model is built on a simple equation: hours multiplied by people multiplied by deliverables. But AI is collapsing the time it takes to produce work. And when the time shrinks, the value of the work; at least in the old model, shrinks with it.
For years we have had a “services page” on our website, but this is a commodity trap. Listing services turns agencies into vendors, vendors compete on price, price competition destroys value. Clients compare bids instead of ideas.
Ten years ago, we dreaded the question “how big are you.” But today, the most interesting agencies aren’t the largest ones. They’re independent, founder-led firms like ours that organize around solving client problems, not staffing projects. We have more ability to organize focused teams, provide senior level thinking and we’re all held accountable for outcomes. We don’t sell effort. We sell solutions to high-value business problems.
Instead of selling:
- Campaigns
- Social posts
- Design
- Messaging
We focus on selling:
- Commercial outcomes
- Growth
- Reputation
- Market positioning
- Brand strength
- Influence
The most valuable agencies are starting to combine the strategic discipline of consulting firms with the storytelling and communications expertise of agencies.
What consulting firms do well
- Diagnose problems
- Define strategy
- Connect work to business value
What agencies do well
- Influence audiences
- Shape narratives
- Create compelling experiences
The future agency looks less like a production shop and more like a business partner. We don’t just take the brief and run with it. We step back, analyze the problem, identify the audience that matters, and recommend the work that will move the needle.
Because we are small, sometimes clients have been wary about giving us some of the bigger work which has been frustrating at times. But, what it has taught us to say to clients is hey, you don’t have to give us the whole account, but give us a challenge that matters, and let us prove what happens when an agency is truly committed to your success. We want to be measured on the success of the work, not the hours it took to produce it. And when we are able to do this well, we get more work.
A new compensation model
And with this goes a new compensation model: the hours model rewards activity. Outcome models reward impact. If the work creates meaningful value for your business, we should participate in that value.
- If we succeed, we should earn more.
- If we don’t deliver impact, we shouldn’t expect to.
AI can generate content in seconds, the value of agencies won’t come from producing more things faster. It will come from understanding which problems are worth solving and delivering work that actually moves the business forward.